The Realities of Redistricting: Following the Rules and by Jonathan Winburn

By Jonathan Winburn

Permitting legislators to choose the citizens that make up their districts is a basic clash of curiosity and relevant main issue for the preferred sovereignty of yankee elections. within the Realities of Redistricting, Jonathan Winburn examines the level of this capability challenge through targeting either the incentives and the limitations dealing with country legislators throughout the redistricting approach. such a lot study on redistricting has a tendency to envision purely the results produced when it comes to partisan earnings or losses; although, we all know less approximately what constrains political mapmakers through the technique. we all know even much less approximately even if constraints outfitted into the method are adequate to restrict the partisan manipulation of either district limitations and electoral results. From the start levels of redistricting to the ensuing results on election day, this booklet analyzes the restrictions and incentives that nation legislators face.By analyzing the whole approach, this e-book investigates who holds the facility within the technique and improves our figuring out of the stipulations lower than which redrawing district obstacles have an important effect on partisan politics through the kingdom. particularly, reformers, who typically argue for commissions, may perhaps locate that targeting the foundations instead of the actors is a greater route to bettering the method. The Realities of Redistricting is an engaging and informative learn for an individual thinking about some of the most contentious tactics within the American process.

Show description

Read or Download The Realities of Redistricting: Following the Rules and Limiting Gerrymandering in State Legislative Redistricting PDF

Best public affairs & policy books

There is No Such Thing as a Natural Disaster: Race, Class, and Hurricane Katrina

There is no normal catastrophe is the 1st finished severe booklet at the catastrophic influence of storm Katrina on New Orleans. The catastrophe will cross down on checklist as one of many worst in American background, no longer least as a result government’s inept and cavalier reaction. however it is additionally an important tale for different purposes; the impression of the typhoon was once asymmetric, and race and sophistication have been deeply implicated within the unevenness.

Impact Issues

High-Beginning/Low-Intermediate point. influence concerns provides 30 discussion-generating subject matters of undying curiosity in enticing two-page devices. The analyzing, concentrating on excessive curiosity social questions, look at the left-hand web page of every unit. The dealing with web page comprises opinion routines and dialogue questions, plus version expressions to assist even high-beginning point scholars take part.

Dangerous trade : arms exports, human rights, and international reputation

The United Nations's groundbreaking fingers alternate Treaty (ATT), which went into impression in 2014, units legally binding criteria to control international fingers exports and displays the starting to be issues towards the numerous function that small and significant traditional hands play in perpetuating human rights violations, clash, and societal instability world wide.

Local Government in the 1990s

Designed as a follow-up to an analogous editors' winning e-book the way forward for neighborhood executive, neighborhood govt within the Nineties offers a definitive and up to date account of the most important alterations that have taken position within the supplier, administration and key parts of carrier supply in united kingdom neighborhood executive lower than Thatcher and significant, and a number of interpretations of most probably destiny advancements.

Extra resources for The Realities of Redistricting: Following the Rules and Limiting Gerrymandering in State Legislative Redistricting

Example text

In this situation, partisan gerrymandering appears more constrained than incumbent gerrymandering. This may actually be the most ideal situation for bipartisan incumbent protection as the parties may prefer the compromise of protecting themselves to pushing partisan agendas. Under partisan commissions, the opposite would appear to be true as the commissioners from outside the legislature should be more concerned with the party’s agenda than that of the incumbents. In these situations, partisan gerrymandering could flourish to the detriment of incumbent protection.

The analysis in each state examines these constraints closer and provides more details for how and when these principles influence or do not influence the production of new districting plans. 1 shows the traditional districting principles in place for the eight states. Each state has a requirement that districts must be contiguous and this factor rarely causes any controversy or discussion as it is well established when drawing districts. Only Washington and Michigan really address this issue in dealing with what constitutes contiguous districts in the Puget Sound area of Washington and the connection between the Upper and Lower Peninsulas in Michigan.

These studies are usually framed in terms of district competitiveness, the seats-votes relationship, or partisan seat gains or losses. Other studies examine these questions in more detail on select cases. 60 50 / Chapter 2 Although the methods and findings may differ, the one common denominator of these studies is the focus on the outcomes produced by the plans at the state, chamber, or district level. By focusing on outcomes, most scholars either assume or theorize about the strategies employed and the changes individual districts underwent during the remapping and do not actually test for these changes.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.97 of 5 – based on 6 votes