Psychoanalysis and Theism: Critical Reflections on the by Benjamin Beit-Hallahmi (ed.)

By Benjamin Beit-Hallahmi (ed.)

How should still we method the mental examine of faith, and the way correct is classical psychoanalysis, pointed out with the writings of Sigmund Freud, to the certainty of faith? Freud's writings on faith were mentioned frequently and proceed to draw consciousness and debate. Psychoanalysis and Theism starts off with an essay by means of Adolf Grünbaum, one of many world's top philosophers of technological know-how and an incisive critic of Freud's paintings. Grünbaum seems to be at Freud's normal claims in regards to the mental mechanisms interested in faith and reveals them missing. Then, in a stunning flip, Grünbaum judges a few of Freud's interpretations of concrete spiritual rules and practices to be not just cogent, yet essential. in terms of the case of the idea in Virgin beginning, Grünbaum reveals an Oedipal interpretation to be our merely choice.

This amazing essay is the stimulus for a symposium with 9 senior students, coming from the fields of philosophy, psychology, sociology, and psychoanalysis, who current their serious reflections on how we must always research faith, how we should always deal with Freud's rules, and what the longer term instructions in mental learn on concrete non secular habit will be. The members convey to this attempt their diverse fields of craftsmanship, from analytical philosophy to experimental psychology. Of certain curiosity are essays which take care of the Virgin delivery doctrine and its attainable mental resources and with the opportunity of destiny psychoanalytic experiences of religion and formality. different essays specialise in Freud's unsleeping and subconscious motivations for learning faith in addition to the hidden biases and lacunae present in the social technological know-how literature on spiritual practices.

This quantity provides a special blend of serious and an expert voices to the talk on Sigmund Freud's legacy.

Show description

Read Online or Download Psychoanalysis and Theism: Critical Reflections on the Grünbaum Thesis PDF

Similar other religions books

The Apocryphal Adam and Eve in Medieval Europe: Vernacular Translations and Adaptations of the Vita Adae et Evae

What occurred to Adam and Eve after their expulsion from paradise? the place the biblical narrative fell silent apocryphal writings took up this fascinating query, particularly together with the Early Christian Latin textual content, the lifetime of Adam and Eve. This account describes the (failed) test of the couple to come back to paradise by way of fasting when immersed in a river, and explores how they coped with new studies corresponding to childbirth and loss of life.

A War Of Witches: A Journey Into The Underworld Of The Contemporary Aztecs

An overheard plot to get rid of an undesirable son-in-law starts this enthralling and extraordinary trip into the Aztec underworld—a international of magical desires and mysterious therapeutic, shadowed by means of a dangerous justice. Aided by way of neighborhood curanderos, or healers, American anthropologist Timothy Knab embarks on a spellbinding experience of sacred Aztec rituals and mystical dream trips into Talocan, the underworld of gods and misplaced souls.

Theism and Ultimate Explanation: The Necessary Shape of Contingency

An expansive, but succinct, research of the Philosophy of faith – from metaphysics via theology. equipped into sections, the textual content first examines truths relating what's attainable and what's invaluable. those chapters lay the root for the book’s moment half – the quest for a metaphysical framework that allows the potential of an final clarification that's right and whole.

Extra resources for Psychoanalysis and Theism: Critical Reflections on the Grünbaum Thesis

Example text

It has made man the measure of all things on Earth-imperfect man, who is never free of pride, self-interest, envy, vanity, and dozens of other defects. . Is it true that man is above everything? " Prima facie, this declaration may sound ingratiatingly modest. But, as it stands, it is morally hollow and theologically question-begging. Whose revelation, one must ask, is to supplant man as the measure of all things? That of the Czarist Russian Orthodox Church? Or the edicts of the Ayatollah Khomeini, as enforced by his mullahs?

But such a gambit could hardly render his delusion of gender-transformation immune to evidential discreditation. Similarly, the belief in the purported efficacy of petitionary prayer to God by well-wishers of fatally ill people is statistically testable and thus disconfirmable by potential medical findings. 2. Both Pope John Paul II (Associated Press dispatch 5-24-1987) and Cardinal O'Connor of New York have endorsed exorcism, which is the therapeutic application of the demonic possession theory of insanity.

But, as we saw, Kung's and Meissner's own insistence that the content of some cardinal religious utterances is incomprehensible renders belief in them meaningless. Thus, it becomes imperative to explain psychologically what stake such theists have in paradoxically demanding credulous assent to those utterances. Unintelligible utterances are neither true nor false. Therefore, they cannot qualify technically as either delusions or illusions. Delusions are, by definition, false beliefs. And Freudian illusions are either true or false.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.45 of 5 – based on 48 votes