Historians' Fallacies : Toward a Logic of Historical Thought by David Hackett Fischer

By David Hackett Fischer

"If one laughs while David Hackett Fischer sits right down to play, one will remain to cheer. His booklet needs to be learn thrice: the 1st in anger, the srcond in laughter, the 3rd in respect....The knowledge is expressed with a certin ruthlessness. Scarcly an important historian escapes unscathed. 10000 participants of the AmericanHistorical organization will rush to the index and breathe a bit more straightforward to discover their names absent.

Show description

Read or Download Historians' Fallacies : Toward a Logic of Historical Thought PDF

Best historiography books

FINDING PEOPLE IN EARLY GREECE

В  development towards a fuller realizing of preclassical Greece was once regular until eventually the Nineteen Fifties, while a common difficulty in all of the human-centered disciplines erupted. students undertook a major reexamination in their instruments and information, generating new manufacturers of historical past, geography, anthropology, archaeology, economics, and sociology.

The Myth of Seneca Falls: Memory and the Women's Suffrage Movement, 1848-1898

The tale of the way the women's rights move begun on the Seneca Falls conference of 1848 is a loved American fable. the traditional account credit founders reminiscent of Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Susan B. Anthony, and Lucretia Mott with defining after which best the crusade for women's suffrage. In her provocative new background, Lisa Tetrault demonstrates that Stanton, Anthony, and their friends progressively created and popularized this origins tale in the course of the moment half the 19th century based on inner circulate dynamics in addition to the racial politics of reminiscence after the Civil conflict.

Critical Discourse Analysis in Historiography: The Case of Hong Kong’s Evolving Political Identity

The publication exhibits how the examine of the evolving discourse hired in the course of a political procedure spanning greater than a decade provides insights for serious discourse research, at the one hand, and figuring out of a true global political technique at the different, thereby demonstrating the aptitude position for serious discourse research in historiography.

Additional info for Historians' Fallacies : Toward a Logic of Historical Thought

Sample text

Elkins, Slavery: A Problem in Ameri­ can Institutional and Intellectual Life, 2d ed. 963 ) , p. ix. " 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. " 9. " l2 The third question commits the fallacy of fictional questions, which is discussed below. All others are examples of the fallacy of many ques­ tions, by any of the definitions listed above. Fehrenbacher's first question assumes that Reconstruction was either "shamefully harsh" or "surpris­ ingly lenient," but maybe it was something else again. The second ques­ tion assumes that there was a single presidential plan of reconstruction, which is doubtful.

And these are questions which will not be resolved before the oceans freeze over. " A scholar who carries this question to the archives can illustrate his answer by reference to historical events; he can add persuasive power to his metaphysical prop­ osition by the appearance of factual solidity. But he can no more hope to resolve the issue of inevitability by empirical research than he can hope to determine by modern methods of quantification the number of angels which might be made to perch upon the head of a proverbial pin .

11 But all of these scholars were themselves unable to keep clear of the problem they condemned. Their works are refutations of the argument that the Civil War was a "needless war," which was precipi­ tated by a "blundering generation" of American political leaders. 19 "As a historian," E. H. ' Life will be drabber. " Historians might also turn their backs upon all aspects of the metaphysical problems raised by determinism versus voluntarism, the comparative reality of individuals and groups, materialism versus idealism, and all manner of other monisms and dualisms.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.83 of 5 – based on 4 votes