Evaluating Evidence: A Positivist Approach to Reading by George Akita

By George Akita

Evaluating Evidence is predicated at the grueling classes discovered via a senior pupil in the course of 3 a long time of tutoring via, and collaboration with, eastern historians. George Akita persevered within the tough job of interpreting documentary assets in jap, such a lot written in calligraphic sort (sôsho), out of the conviction in their centrality to the historian’s craft and his dedication to a positivist method to investigate and scholarship. He argues forcefully during this quantity for an inductive technique within which the student seeks out evidence on an issue and, via commentary and exam of an intensive physique of knowledge, is ready to parent styles till it really is attainable to formulate yes propositions.

In his creation, Akita relates how and why he made up our minds to undertake a positivist method and explains what he capability via the time period because it applies to humanistic reviews. He enumerates the problems associated with analyzing basic resources in jap by way of taking a look at various unpublished and released fabrics and deciding on a massive challenge in interpreting released fundamental assets: the intervention of editors and compilers. He illustrates the pitfalls of such intervention via evaluating the lately released seventeen-volume diary of major Minister Hara Takashi (1856–1921), a photograph replica of the diary in Hara’s personal hand, and an previous released model. utilizing records regarding Yamagata Aritomo (1838–1922), a determine of important value in Japan’s post-Restoration political historical past, he demonstrates using released and transcribed basic assets to maintain, query, or enhance many of the subject matters and techniques followed through non-Japanese students engaged on smooth eastern heritage. He ends his inquiry with "case studies," reading heavily the equipment of the hugely acclaimed American historians John W. Dower and Herbert P. Bix.

Show description

Read or Download Evaluating Evidence: A Positivist Approach to Reading Sources on Modern Japan PDF

Best historiography books

FINDING PEOPLE IN EARLY GREECE

В  growth towards a fuller figuring out of preclassical Greece used to be regular until eventually the Nineteen Fifties, while a common predicament in all of the human-centered disciplines erupted. students undertook a major reexamination in their instruments and information, generating new manufacturers of heritage, geography, anthropology, archaeology, economics, and sociology.

The Myth of Seneca Falls: Memory and the Women's Suffrage Movement, 1848-1898

The tale of ways the women's rights move all started on the Seneca Falls conference of 1848 is a loved American delusion. the traditional account credit founders similar to Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Susan B. Anthony, and Lucretia Mott with defining after which prime the crusade for women's suffrage. In her provocative new historical past, Lisa Tetrault demonstrates that Stanton, Anthony, and their friends progressively created and popularized this origins tale in the course of the moment half the 19th century in keeping with inner circulation dynamics in addition to the racial politics of reminiscence after the Civil warfare.

Critical Discourse Analysis in Historiography: The Case of Hong Kong’s Evolving Political Identity

The e-book exhibits how the learn of the evolving discourse hired in the course of a political technique spanning greater than a decade offers insights for serious discourse research, at the one hand, and figuring out of a true international political method at the different, thereby demonstrating the aptitude position for severe discourse research in historiography.

Additional resources for Evaluating Evidence: A Positivist Approach to Reading Sources on Modern Japan

Example text

She knew that Itô Takashi, a friend and colleague since 1967, had arranged it and that the subject of the speech, “Gaikoku kara Mita Nihon Kensei no Ayumi: Sono Hyakunen,” the venue, and the reason for the celebration represented the culmination of all my years of research and writing on the political history of modern Japan. ”34 Itô Takashi’s Legacy Robert A. D. 35 He did what many nonJapanese reviewers, journalists, and editorial writers did not, that is, he actually read and compared high school textbooks published from the end of the Allied Occupation of Japan to the 1999 edition in use for the 2002 school year.

Still, it was difficult to accept Itô’s advice to join him, his colleagues, and graduate students in transcribing letters written in sôsho since I was fifty-one years old at the time. He did not accept the excuse of age and countered with his reasons for making the suggestion. He said that his graduate students were doing it, so the challenge was not insurmountable. Comparison with Tôdai graduate students was flattering, though his logic was unconvincing. The rest of his arguments were more persuasive.

Still, the published Shinagawa Yajirô Kankei Monjo (SYKM) is now in its sixth volume with another projected. The published YAKM will be in three volumes. The question of who had selected the letters that remain has been long a puzzle, since no scholar or group of scholars had attempted to read, much less transcribe, the whole collection written almost entirely in sôsho in countless different styles. The transcription has been Reading Primary Documents 33 completed and two volumes out of three have been published (2004, 2006), so the riddle may be closer to solution.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.66 of 5 – based on 34 votes